Rejected clean pictures, drawn again

Follow-up: original photo vs cut-out (A/B/C) →

Every preview piece of Eva, Andraz and Ivona that is ready but whose clean picture ended rejected (24 pieces; Andraz had none). Each was drawn once more, today, with production's exact request (the upright cut-out at 1024 px on grey, the stored key colour, the pressed prompt from CleanPrompt.ts), keyed and framed as production stores it, and judged with production's Clef compare: it passes when min(same, faithful) ≥ 0.5. The "diagnostic" line is a separate Clef call with finer questions, to hint at what the judge sees as different; it is not part of production's gate.

Now: 11 pass, 12 fail, 1 refused by Muse.

bags 1 of 2 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Ivona bags white			PASS same 0.71 faithful 0.73 min 0.71 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.95 · colour 0.94 · print 0.32 · shape 0.64 · details 0.56 · count 0.91 · whole 0.85	Good drawing.
Eva bags brown			FAIL same 0.24 faithful 0.27 min 0.24 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.92 · colour 0.92 · print 0.19 · shape 0.27 · details 0.38 · count 0.87 · whole 0.77	Drawing is wrong: the slouchy shoulder bag with a long tab became a different, structured crossbody flap bag. Correct reject.

boots 1 of 1 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva boots black			PASS same 0.53 faithful 0.54 min 0.53 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.95 · colour 0.95 · print 0.39 · shape 0.44 · details 0.28 · count 0.81 · whole 0.71	Good drawing (pair stood upright); scraped through at 0.53.

coats 1 of 1 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Ivona coats beige			PASS same 0.55 faithful 0.60 min 0.55 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.97 · colour 0.89 · print 0.47 · shape 0.73 · details 0.30 · count 0.93 · whole 0.92	Good drawing; 0.55.

jeans 0 of 3 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Ivona jeans navy			FAIL same 0.25 faithful 0.29 min 0.25 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.94 · colour 0.90 · print 0.17 · shape 0.39 · details 0.34 · count 0.43 · whole 0.06	Cut-out is a fragment: one leg plus two loose pieces. The drawing is a plausible pair of dark jeans, but the judge compares it with a shape that is not a whole garment (diagnostic 'whole' 0.06). A fragment problem, not a drawing problem.
Ivona jeans blue			FAIL same 0.25 faithful 0.21 min 0.21 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.94 · colour 0.65 · print 0.13 · shape 0.32 · details 0.31 · count 0.77 · whole 0.35	Cut-out is two crumpled, cropped legs with no waistband. Muse invented a whole pair of light jeans; the colour and wash match, the rest cannot be checked. Fragment.
Ivona jeans blue			FAIL same 0.30 faithful 0.23 min 0.23 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.96 · colour 0.56 · print 0.23 · shape 0.51 · details 0.48 · count 0.84 · whole 0.52	Drawing is close: same wash, rip at the knee and the pin at the hem kept; straightened from a baggy, flared fit to a straight leg. Borderline; the judge is strict on the changed silhouette.

knitwear 0 of 1 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva knitwear black			FAIL same 0.40 faithful 0.30 min 0.30 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.93 · colour 0.96 · print 0.21 · shape 0.32 · details 0.08 · count 0.84 · whole 0.83	Drawing is wrong: the lace-up ties are gone and a plain black top came back. (Earlier I read the cut-out as the back; the original product shot shows the same lace-up side, so it may be its front.) The follow-up spike drew it from the original too and the ties vanished every time: the pressed wording erases them. Correct reject.

loungewear 0 of 1 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva loungewear white, yellow, purple			FAIL same 0.60 faithful 0.04 min 0.04 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.96 · colour 0.91 · print 0.05 · shape 0.81 · details 0.71 · count 0.53 · whole 0.74	Drawing is wrong: the tee's small character prints and logo are dropped, a plain white tee came back (faithful 0.04). Correct reject.

outdoorShoes 1 of 2 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva outdoorShoes beige			PASS same 0.68 faithful 0.60 min 0.60 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.95 · colour 0.85 · print 0.49 · shape 0.67 · details 0.54 · count 0.89 · whole 0.89	Good drawing (pair seen from above).
Eva outdoorShoes grey			FAIL same 0.63 faithful 0.36 min 0.36 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.96 · colour 0.90 · print 0.22 · shape 0.67 · details 0.33 · count 0.66 · whole 0.87	Same boot, but the cut-out is a side view and the drawing a head-on front view: the side logo and panels cannot be compared, so faithful 0.36. The drawing changed the angle.

sandals 2 of 2 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva sandals green			PASS same 0.66 faithful 0.63 min 0.63 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.94 · colour 0.87 · print 0.71 · shape 0.86 · details 0.66 · count 0.91 · whole 0.91	Good drawing.
Eva sandals beige			PASS same 0.65 faithful 0.66 min 0.65 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.90 · colour 0.89 · print 0.38 · shape 0.75 · details 0.73 · count 0.70 · whole 0.84	Good drawing.

shortSleeveTops 1 of 1 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva shortSleeveTops white			PASS same 0.66 faithful 0.89 min 0.66 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.96 · colour 0.96 · print 0.42 · shape 0.85 · details 0.81 · count 0.92 · whole 0.93	Good drawing.

sleevelessTops 2 of 4 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva sleevelessTops black			PASS same 0.77 faithful 0.76 min 0.76 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.94 · colour 0.96 · print 0.65 · shape 0.68 · details 0.50 · count 0.84 · whole 0.76	Good drawing.
Eva sleevelessTops black			FAIL same 0.56 faithful 0.38 min 0.38 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.96 · colour 0.95 · print 0.11 · shape 0.80 · details 0.59 · count 0.85 · whole 0.87	Drawing is almost right; the small round logo on the chest was dropped. Faithful 0.38 for one missing detail: defensible but strict.
Eva sleevelessTops red			PASS same 0.62 faithful 0.60 min 0.60 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.75 · colour 0.90 · print 0.27 · shape 0.68 · details 0.52 · count 0.85 · whole 0.83	Good drawing, tidied from a crumpled photo.
Eva sleevelessTops grey		Muse refused (content filter)	NO DRAWING muse: Error: no image: {"error":{"code":"content_policy_violation","message":"The response was filtered due to the promp	Muse's content filter refused it (a grey bodysuit / underwear-like garment). Production would end this as failed, not rejected.

sportswear 1 of 2 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva sportswear orange			PASS same 0.51 faithful 0.55 min 0.51 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.95 · colour 0.75 · print 0.60 · shape 0.49 · details 0.47 · count 0.85 · whole 0.54	Good drawing; scraped through at 0.51.
Eva sportswear black			FAIL same 0.12 faithful 0.09 min 0.09 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.94 · colour 0.95 · print 0.20 · shape 0.30 · details 0.08 · count 0.80 · whole 0.89	Drawing is wrong: the crossed straps became plain straight straps. The follow-up spike shows the same from the original photo: 'straps fall straight and symmetrically' erases them. Correct reject.

swimwear 1 of 1 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Eva swimwear red, blue, white			PASS same 0.60 faithful 0.71 min 0.60 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.91 · colour 0.87 · print 0.79 · shape 0.79 · details 0.66 · count 0.88 · whole 0.84	Good drawing, print kept.

trousers 0 of 3 pass

Piece	Cut-out, as sent to Muse	Fresh drawing, keyed as stored	Judge	What I see
Ivona trousers grey			FAIL same 0.38 faithful 0.46 min 0.38 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.95 · colour 0.91 · print 0.52 · shape 0.46 · details 0.22 · count 0.85 · whole 0.36	Drawing looks faithful: grey pleated trousers with gathered cuffs and button, straightened from a twisted, cut-off cut-out. Judge looks too strict (the cut-out is not whole: 0.36).
Ivona trousers white			FAIL same 0.43 faithful 0.51 min 0.43 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.93 · colour 0.75 · print 0.38 · shape 0.49 · details 0.29 · count 0.80 · whole 0.57	Cut-out is a folded, torn fragment of white trousers; the drawing keeps the asymmetric waist. Plausible; the judge cannot match the shapes. Fragment.
Eva trousers black			FAIL same 0.46 faithful 0.58 min 0.46 vs 0.50 diagnostic (not the gate): type 0.96 · colour 0.86 · print 0.56 · shape 0.48 · details 0.39 · count 0.88 · whole 0.78	Drawing is practically identical to the cut-out (plain black trousers). Same 0.46: this is the judge being noisy, not the drawing.